Fleck 5600 vs Aquasure – Making the Right Water Softener Choice
Hard water can cause serious damage to your home’s plumbing, appliances, and daily routines. The Fleck 5600 and Aquasure water softeners stand out as top solutions to these problems. Making a choice between these popular brands can be tricky.
We took our time to get into both systems and help you decide better. Fleck’s reputation for reliability makes it a solid choice. Aquasure has become a strong match for Fleck with groundbreaking features and better prices. This detailed look covers everything from tech specs to setup needs. You’ll learn about the long-term value and performance that will help you pick the right water softener for your home.
Technical Specifications Comparison
These water softeners have distinct technical capabilities that set them apart. The Fleck 5600 features a 48,000-grain capacity that works great for medium to large households. Aquasure proves no match for flexibility with models ranging from 20,000 to 64,000 grains, which fits different household sizes.
The flow rates show most important differences between these systems. The Fleck 5600’s efficient flow system keeps water pressure steady, and Aquasure’s 48,000-grain model pushes up to 15 gallons per minute. Both systems handle tough water conditions well, with Aquasure managing up to 110 GPG (grains per gallon).
Key Specifications Comparison:
| Feature | Fleck 5600 | Aquasure |
|---|---|---|
| Control Type | Manual dial | Digital LCD |
| Salt Storage | Standard tank | 160 lbs capacity |
| Max Flow Rate | 12-15 GPM | 8-15 GPM |
Each system’s control mechanism takes a unique approach. Fleck’s straightforward manual controls are prominent for their durability and reliability. Aquasure responds with a user-friendly digital interface that includes automatic settings and programming options.
The regeneration systems work differently in each model. The Fleck 5600 uses a meter-based regeneration process that kicks in only as needed. Aquasure’s automatic digital metered control helps save water while keeping performance optimal.
Salt storage and regeneration cycles show how each system thinks differently. Aquasure models typically need regeneration every 3-5 days. The Fleck system stretches these intervals based on your actual water usage.
Installation and Setup Process
Our comparison reveals notable differences in how these systems are installed. The Aquasure excels with its DIY-friendly approach. It comes with quick-connect fittings and clear instructions. The Fleck 5600 setup is straightforward, but you might need expert help to get everything right.
DIY vs Professional Installation Requirements
Homeowners who know their way around simple plumbing tasks can set up the Fleck 5600SXT in a few hours. Professional installation remains a budget-friendly choice. The Aquasure system makes DIY installation more available with comprehensive manuals and user-friendly parts.
Original Programming and Configuration
Each model brings a unique programming experience:
- Aquasure comes with an automatic digital metered control head that precisely handles backwashing and regeneration
- Fleck needs initial setup but provides reliable, easy-to-follow programming options
Space Requirements and Plumbing Considerations
Space planning plays a vital role in successful installation. The Fleck system needs approximately 12 square feet for tanks and maintenance access. The Aquasure 48,000-grain model requires this much space:
- Brine tank dimensions: 15″ x 37″
- Total system weight: 90 lbs (dry)
These systems need indoor installation close to the main water line with power and drainage access. A minimum ten-foot pipe distance between the softener and water heater prevents possible damage.
Performance and Efficiency Analysis
Tests show these water softeners work quite differently under ground conditions. Both systems do a great job removing hardness-causing minerals, but they take different paths to improve efficiency.
Water Softening Effectiveness
The Fleck 5600 excels at removing iron, manganese, and other impurities from water. The Aquasure Harmony Series tackles calcium and magnesium effectively and prevents scale buildup throughout your home’s plumbing system.
Salt and Water Usage Efficiency
The systems show clear differences in regeneration patterns and resource use. The Aquasure system needs regeneration every 3-5 days, using 45-60 gallons of water and 12-15 pounds of salt per regeneration cycle. The Fleck’s metered regeneration system kicks in based on actual water usage, which makes resource management more efficient.
Key efficiency features:
- Aquasure’s flow rate reaches up to 12 GPM for consistent supply
- Fleck’s specialized iron removal system improves overall performance
Energy Consumption Comparison
Both systems want to keep power use low. The Aquasure model uses simpler components that need less power. The Fleck’s advanced features might use slightly more energy, but its efficient regeneration cycles make up for this difference.
| Feature | Fleck 5600 | Aquasure |
|---|---|---|
| Regeneration Frequency | Usage-based | Every 3-5 days |
| Water Usage/Cycle | Variable | 45-60 gallons |
| Flow Rate | High efficiency | 8-12 GPM |
Long-term Value Assessment
Our analysis of these water softeners’ long-term investment value reveals notable differences in both the original costs and ongoing expenses.
Initial Cost vs Operating Expenses
A price comparison shows the Aquasure Harmony Series costs USD 549.50 for the 48,000-grain model, and the Fleck 5600SXT ranges between USD 600-700. The original price is just one part of the equation. These systems need ongoing salt and water expenses, and regeneration cycles use 45-60 gallons per cycle.
Maintenance Requirements and Costs
Both systems need regular maintenance to work at their best. The Aquasure’s performance depends on consistent salt reservoir checks and brine tank cleaning. The system works best with:
- Regular brine tank cleaning
- Monthly system inspections
- Salt level monitoring
Durability and Expected Lifespan
Water softener resin typically needs replacement after 10 years of normal use. The lifespan can drop to 5 years with high chlorine or iron levels. The Fleck system stands out because of its durable construction and proven track record.
| Feature | Fleck 5600 | Aquasure |
|---|---|---|
| Warranty Coverage | Extended warranty | 5-year warranty |
| Expected Resin Life | 10 years* | 10 years* |
| Build Quality | Industrial-grade | Residential-grade |
*Under normal conditions without high chlorine/iron levels
These systems are a great value, and the Fleck’s higher original cost often balances out through its extended durability and efficient operation.
Comparison Table
| Feature | Fleck 5600 | Aquasure |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 48,000 grains | 20,000 to 64,000 grains |
| Maximum Flow Rate | 12-15 GPM | 8-15 GPM |
| Control System | Manual dial | Digital LCD |
| Salt Storage | Standard tank | 160 lbs capacity |
| Regeneration Type | Meter-based | Automatic digital metered |
| Regeneration Frequency | Based on water usage | Every 3-5 days |
| Water Usage per Regeneration | Not mentioned | 45-60 gallons |
| Salt Usage per Regeneration | Not mentioned | 12-15 pounds |
| Maximum Hardness Removal | Not mentioned | Up to 110 GPG |
| Installation Approach | May require professional guidance | DIY-friendly with quick-connect fittings |
| Price Range (48,000-grain model) | $600-700 | $549.50 |
| Warranty | Extended warranty | 5-year warranty |
| Expected Resin Life | 10 years (under normal conditions) | 10 years (under normal conditions) |
| Build Quality | Industrial-grade | Residential-grade |
Conclusion
The Fleck 5600 and Aquasure water softeners are great options for homeowners who want to solve their hard water problems. We tested both systems and found unique benefits in each one. The Fleck 5600 shines with its industrial-grade build quality, manual controls that work well, and a smart regeneration system based on actual usage. Aquasure stands out with its budget-friendly price, easy-to-use digital controls, and flexible capacity that ranges from 20,000 to 64,000 grains.
Your household’s specific needs will determine which system works best for you. Aquasure works great for DIY homeowners who want modern features without breaking the bank. The Fleck 5600’s higher original cost comes with better durability and proven results that many users value.
Our tests showed both systems work well to treat hard water, but they use different methods. Fleck’s meter-based regeneration helps save resources, while Aquasure’s preset cycles deliver reliable performance. Each system’s warranty, upkeep needs, and expected lifespan match their market position – Fleck as a premium industrial choice and Aquasure as a solid home solution.
These systems can work well depending on your needs. The Fleck 5600 is perfect if you want proven reliability and smooth operation. Aquasure gives you great value with its modern features and available design.
FAQs
Q1. Which water softener is more suitable for DIY installation?
The Aquasure water softener is generally more DIY-friendly, featuring quick-connect fittings and clear instructions. While the Fleck 5600 can be installed by homeowners with basic plumbing skills, it may benefit from professional guidance for optimal setup.
Q2. How do the Fleck 5600 and Aquasure compare in terms of water softening capacity?
The Fleck 5600 typically comes with a 48,000-grain capacity, suitable for medium to large households. Aquasure offers more flexibility with models ranging from 20,000 to 64,000 grains, catering to various household sizes.
Q3. What are the differences in regeneration processes between these two systems?
The Fleck 5600 uses a meter-based regeneration process, activating only when necessary based on actual water usage. Aquasure’s system features automatic digital metered control, with typical regeneration occurring every 3-5 days.
Q4. How do the long-term costs compare between Fleck 5600 and Aquasure?
While the Aquasure Harmony Series (48,000-grain model) has a lower initial cost at around $549.50, the Fleck 5600SXT’s higher upfront cost (typically $600-700) often balances out through its extended durability and efficient operation over time.
Q5. What are the key differences in control systems between these water softeners?
The Fleck 5600 features straightforward manual controls known for durability and reliability. In contrast, Aquasure offers a user-friendly digital interface with automatic settings and programming options, providing more modern functionality.
