Sedici Helmets: Strada 3 Carbon vs Shoei Air 2 – Which is Better?
When it comes to motorcycle safety, choosing the right helmet is crucial. Sedici helmets have gained popularity among riders for their lightweight construction and advanced safety features. This comparison between the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and the Shoei Air 2 aims to help riders make an informed decision about which full face helmet best suits their needs.
Both helmets boast aerodynamic designs and offer superior airflow for rider comfort. The Strada 3 Carbon features a carbon fiber shell, while the Shoei Air 2 utilizes a fiberglass composite. This article will examine their safety certifications, comfort elements like cheek pads and chin curtains, visor mechanisms, and overall value. By comparing these two top contenders, riders can find the ideal helmet for their riding style and budget.
Design and Construction
The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 helmets showcase distinct design philosophies and construction techniques, each aiming to provide riders with optimal protection and comfort.
Shell Material
The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon features a carbon composite shell that incorporates a proprietary blend of carbon fiber, nylon, DuPont Kevlar®, and military-spec resin. This combination results in a lighter and stronger shell compared to traditional materials. The 5-layer construction creates a rigid exterior while reducing weight, demonstrating Sedici’s commitment to advanced helmet technology.
In contrast, the Shoei Air 2 utilizes a Multi-Ply Matrix AIM (Advanced Integrated Matrix) shell. This fiberglass composite material offers a balance of strength and flexibility, providing excellent impact resistance and durability.
Weight
When it comes to weight, both helmets strive for lightness without compromising safety. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon has managed to shed 5 ounces compared to its predecessor in size Large, which is equivalent to about 6 AA batteries. This weight reduction contributes to increased comfort and reduced fatigue during long rides.
The Shoei Air 2, while specific weight details are not provided, is described as being slightly lighter than some of its competitors. The shell’s construction in the Shoei Air 2 aims to balance protection and weight, ensuring a comfortable fit for extended periods of use.
Aerodynamics
Both helmets have been designed with aerodynamics in mind, focusing on reducing drag and improving stability at high speeds. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon’s shell has been aerodynamically improved to be more stable and quieter at speed, lessening drag and wind noise while providing a sleek appearance. The helmet’s thoughtfully designed shell reduces turbulence in any riding position, allowing riders to stay focused on the road ahead.
The Shoei Air 2 also boasts advanced aerodynamics. Its progressive shell shape is compact and uniquely streamlined to reduce air resistance and drag. This design helps minimize wind noise and fatigue during long rides, enhancing overall rider comfort.
Both helmets feature strategically placed vents to optimize airflow. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon has redesigned intake and exhaust vents based on rider feedback, with relocated and upgraded front and top vents for easier customization of airflow. The Shoei Air 2 incorporates 3 intake and 5 exhaust vents, providing efficient ventilation throughout the helmet.
In terms of overall aerodynamic performance, both helmets are considered comparable, with riders reporting minimal buffeting and good stability at highway speeds. However, it’s worth noting that individual experiences may vary depending on riding style and conditions.
Safety Features
When it comes to protecting riders, both the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 helmets offer advanced safety features designed to minimize the risk of injury in the event of a crash.
Impact Protection
The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon boasts a 5-layer shell construction that combines carbon fiber, nylon, DuPont Kevlar®, and military-spec resin. This proprietary blend results in a strong, rigid exterior while reducing weight. The helmet’s design incorporates elements typically reserved for racing helmets, such as a curved lower portion of the shell to limit collarbone contact during a crash.
On the other hand, the Shoei Air 2 utilizes an Advanced Integrated Matrix (AIM) composite fiber construction. This shell works in conjunction with a multi-density polystyrene shock-absorbing liner to absorb impacts effectively. The AIM technology involves layering fiberglass with proprietary organic fiber layers to produce a strong yet flexible helmet shell.
Both helmets feature strategically designed shells to manage energy transfer during impacts. However, it’s worth noting that the specific impact absorption capabilities can only be accurately determined through independent testing.
Certifications
The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon meets or exceeds DOT and ECE 22.06 standards. ECE 22.06 is a more comprehensive European standard that extends and increases the testing requirements of its predecessor, ECE 22.05. This certification involves analyzing 18 impact points and increased impact speed testing, providing a higher level of assurance for rider safety.
The Shoei Air 2 is DOT approved for the US market and ECE certified for European territories. While specific details about its ECE certification version are not provided, it’s important to note that ECE standards are generally considered more rigorous than DOT requirements.
Visor System
Both helmets feature advanced visor systems designed to enhance safety and visibility. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon comes with an FF-80 face shield, a 2mm polycarbonate flat shield that provides optically correct and clear vision. The shield is Pinlock ready, allowing for the installation of a Pinlock insert to prevent fogging.
The Shoei Air 2 also offers a Pinlock-ready visor, with the Pinlock insert included in the box. This anti-fog system creates a thermal barrier and absorbs moisture, ensuring clear vision in various weather conditions. The visor also features a new ‘cracked open’ position to assist with defogging when needed.
Both helmets incorporate quick-release face shield designs for easy shield changes, enhancing convenience and safety. The Shoei Air 2 utilizes a CNS-1 spring-loaded baseplate system that pulls the shield back tightly to the weather seal, effectively keeping out air and wind when closed.
While both helmets prioritize safety through their construction, certifications, and visor systems, riders should always ensure a proper fit for optimal protection. A correctly sized and fitted helmet, regardless of price or certification, will provide better protection than an ill-fitting one with higher certifications.
Comfort and Fit
When it comes to comfort and fit, both the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 helmets offer features designed to enhance the riding experience. Let’s take a closer look at their interior padding, ventilation systems, and noise reduction capabilities.
Interior Padding
The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon boasts a fully removable and washable inner lining, which is a standout feature for a helmet in its price range. This allows riders to keep their helmet fresh and clean, especially after long rides or during hot weather. The cheek pads are designed to contour to the rider’s face, providing a snug fit that helps reduce wind noise.
On the other hand, the Shoei Air 2 takes comfort a step further with its dry-cool material lining. This advanced fabric wicks away sweat and helps remove heat from inside the helmet, contributing to overall rider comfort. The interior padding of the Shoei Air 2 is also fully removable and washable, making maintenance a breeze.
Both helmets offer adjustable padding options, allowing riders to fine-tune the fit. However, it’s worth noting that the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon provides 5mm adjustment pads, giving riders more flexibility in customizing their fit.
Ventilation
Efficient airflow is crucial for rider comfort, especially during long rides or in warm weather. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon features a redesigned ventilation system based on rider feedback. It incorporates relocated and upgraded front and top vents, allowing for easier customization of airflow. The helmet’s channel cutouts work to direct air from the front to the back, providing impressive ventilation for a helmet in its price range.
The Shoei Air 2 takes ventilation to the next level with its advanced system. It includes intakes on both the chin bar and side cowls, as well as a diffusing vent on top. This design helps move air around before expelling it through the rear exhaust, making it particularly effective for both commuting and adventure riding where overheating can be a concern.
Both helmets feature chin vents that help prevent shield fogging and provide additional ventilation around the jaw area. However, the Shoei Air 2’s ventilation system is generally considered more advanced and effective in its overall performance.
Noise Reduction
For many riders, a quiet helmet is essential for long-term comfort and hearing protection. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon’s aerodynamic design helps minimize wind noise, with the cheek pads working to wrap around the head and reduce turbulence. The helmet also features a removable chin curtain, which riders can use to further block wind and reduce noise if desired.
The Shoei Air 2 is known for its exceptional noise reduction capabilities. Its aerodynamic shell design, combined with the carefully engineered interior padding, creates a quiet riding environment. The helmet’s spring-loaded CNS-1 baseplate system ensures a tight seal when the visor is closed, effectively keeping out wind and reducing noise.
While both helmets strive to provide a quiet riding experience, the Shoei Air 2 generally edges out in this category, offering one of the quietest rides in its class. However, it’s important to note that perceived noise levels can vary depending on individual riding styles, motorcycle types, and wind conditions.
In conclusion, both the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 offer impressive comfort and fit features. The Sedici provides excellent value with its removable lining and adjustable fit, while the Shoei excels in advanced ventilation and noise reduction. Riders should consider their specific needs and budget when choosing between these two quality full face helmets.
Visor and Field of View
The visor and field of view are crucial aspects of any full face helmet, directly impacting rider safety and comfort. Both the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 offer advanced features in this area.
Optical Clarity
The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon comes with an FF-80 face shield, a 2mm polycarbonate flat shield that provides optically correct and clear vision. While it may not be considered optically perfect like some high-end helmets, it offers good clarity for its price range. The shield has a large, ¾” wide tapered stripe that runs along the bottom, which some riders may find noticeable.
The Shoei Air 2 utilizes a CNS-1 face shield, which is designed to offer a broader and taller field of vision compared to its predecessors. This shield is manufactured using a 3D injection-molding process, ensuring a clear view across the entire sightline.
Anti-Fog Properties
Both helmets address the common issue of visor fogging, albeit through different methods. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon is Pinlock ready, allowing for the installation of a Pinlock insert to prevent fogging. Interestingly, even without the Pinlock insert, the main visor of the Sedici helmet shows impressive anti-fog properties. It may fog up briefly if exhaled upon, but the airflow from the chin bar vent clears it in milliseconds.
The Shoei Air 2 comes with a Pinlock EVO fog-resistant system included. This system utilizes a unique double visor setup where a Pinlock insert, made of a moisture-absorbing material, is attached to the inside of the helmet’s main visor. The space between the insert and the visor creates an insulating air pocket, effectively preventing fogging.
Sun Visor
The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon features a convenient drop-down, tinted sun lens. This integrated sun visor is a valuable feature, especially for riders who frequently encounter varying light conditions. However, some users have noted that the sun visor can fog up more easily than the main visor, though this can be mitigated using the chin bar ventilation.
The Shoei Air 2 also includes an integrated sun shield. This built-in, retractable sun shield provides instant relief from sun glare and can be easily adjusted even while riding. This feature enhances rider comfort and safety by allowing quick adaptation to changing light conditions without the need to stop and change visors.
Both helmets prioritize clear vision and adaptability to different lighting conditions, crucial factors for rider safety. The Shoei Air 2 seems to have a slight edge in terms of advanced anti-fog technology and optical clarity, while the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon offers impressive features for its price point. Ultimately, the choice between these two full face helmets will depend on individual preferences and budget considerations.
Additional Features
Both the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 helmets offer extra features that enhance their functionality and rider experience.
Communication System Compatibility
The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 are designed with communication system compatibility in mind. Both helmets feature 45mm speaker pockets, allowing riders to easily install aftermarket Bluetooth communication devices. This feature is particularly useful for those who enjoy group rides or need to stay connected while on the road.
The Shoei Air 2 takes communication compatibility a step further. It is specifically designed to be compatible with the SENA SRL2 and SRL-MESH Bluetooth headsets. This integration allows for seamless installation and optimal performance of these communication systems, enhancing the overall riding experience.
Removable/Washable Liners
Both helmets prioritize hygiene and comfort with their removable and washable interior liners. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon features a fully removable and washable inner lining, which is impressive for a helmet in its price range. This allows riders to keep their helmet fresh and clean, especially after long rides or during hot weather.
The Shoei Air 2 goes a step further with its 3D Max-Dry Interior System. This system is not only fully removable and washable but also replaceable. The multi-layer cheek pads offer a customizable fit, improving comfort and stabilization. The moisture-wicking material used in the liner helps keep riders cool and dry during rides, enhancing overall comfort.
Regular cleaning of these liners is essential for maintaining helmet hygiene. Most manufacturers recommend cleaning the liners at least once a month, but always check the specific care instructions for your helmet model.
Chin Curtain
The chin curtain is an often-overlooked feature that can significantly impact a helmet’s performance. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon comes with a removable chin curtain. This feature helps reduce wind noise and airflow from the front of the helmet, which can be particularly beneficial during colder rides.
The Shoei Air 2 also includes a chin curtain, which works in conjunction with the helmet’s aerodynamic design to reduce wind noise. However, some riders have noted that removing the chin curtain can increase airflow, which may be preferable in warmer conditions.
It’s worth noting that the effectiveness of chin curtains can vary between helmet models and individual preferences. Some riders find them essential for noise reduction and comfort, while others prefer to ride without them for increased ventilation.
Both the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 offer these additional features, enhancing their functionality beyond basic protection. The choice between these full face helmets often comes down to personal preference and specific riding needs.
Price and Value
When comparing the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 helmets, price and value are crucial factors to consider. Both helmets offer unique features and benefits, but their price points differ significantly.
Cost Comparison
The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon is a more budget-friendly option, retailing at around USD 199.99. This price point makes it an attractive choice for riders looking for a high-quality full face helmet without breaking the bank. Despite its affordable price, the Strada 3 Carbon offers features typically found in more expensive helmets, such as a carbon fiber shell and advanced ventilation system.
In contrast, the Shoei Air 2 is positioned as a premium helmet, with prices ranging from USD 550.00 to USD 600.00. This higher price reflects Shoei’s reputation for quality and advanced technology in helmet manufacturing. The Air 2’s cost includes features like the advanced ventilation system, superior noise reduction, and compatibility with specific communication systems.
It’s worth noting that while the price difference is substantial, both helmets meet or exceed safety standards. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon, in particular, offers impressive value for its price point, punching above its weight class in terms of features and construction quality.
Warranty
Warranty coverage is an important aspect of a helmet’s overall value. Shoei offers a comprehensive warranty for their helmets, including the Air 2. Their warranty covers manufacturing defects for five years from the purchase date or seven years from the date of manufacture, whichever comes first. This extended warranty period provides peace of mind for riders investing in a premium helmet.
While specific warranty information for the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon wasn’t provided in the factual keypoints, it’s common for helmet manufacturers to offer warranties covering manufacturing defects. Potential buyers should inquire about warranty details when considering this helmet.
Long-Term Durability
Long-term durability is a crucial factor in assessing a helmet’s value. The Shoei Air 2, with its advanced construction techniques and materials, is built to last. Its multi-ply matrix shell, combining fiberglass, organic and glass fibers, and synthetic resin, contributes to its durability and long-term performance.
The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon, despite its lower price point, also demonstrates impressive durability. Its carbon fiber shell provides excellent strength-to-weight ratio, potentially extending the helmet’s lifespan. However, some users have reported minor issues, such as the chin skirt popping off easily, which may affect long-term durability.
Both helmets feature removable and washable liners, which contribute to their longevity by allowing for easy maintenance and hygiene. This feature is particularly noteworthy in the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon, as it’s not always common in helmets at this price point.
When considering long-term value, it’s important to factor in potential replacement costs for components like visors. High-end helmets often have more expensive replacement parts, which could impact the overall cost of ownership over time.
In conclusion, both the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 offer value in their respective price ranges. The Sedici provides impressive features and performance for its price, making it an excellent choice for budget-conscious riders. The Shoei Air 2, while more expensive, justifies its price with advanced technology, superior comfort, and a comprehensive warranty. The choice between these full face helmets ultimately depends on individual budget constraints and specific riding needs.
Conclusion
The comparison between the Sedici Strada 3 Carbon and Shoei Air 2 helmets sheds light on the diverse options available to riders. Both helmets have their strong points, with the Sedici offering impressive features at a budget-friendly price, while the Shoei brings advanced technology and premium comfort to the table. The choice between these full face helmets boils down to individual needs, riding style, and budget constraints.
In the end, both helmets prioritize rider safety and comfort, albeit through different approaches. The Sedici Strada 3 Carbon proves that quality doesn’t always come with a hefty price tag, while the Shoei Air 2 shows what’s possible with a higher investment. Whether you’re a seasoned rider or just starting out, taking the time to consider these factors will help you find the helmet that best suits your needs and enhances your riding experience.
FAQs
Who is the manufacturer of Sedici helmets?
Sedici helmets are produced by Comoto Holdings, which is the parent company of retailers such as Revzilla, J&P Cycles, and Cycle Gear, making Sedici a house brand for these stores.
What is the weight of the Sedici Strada II helmet?
The Sedici Strada II helmet has a weight of approximately 3.5 pounds (1.6 kilograms), which is slightly heavier than the average weight of typical fiberglass helmets.
Which company produces the best motorcycle helmets as of 2024?
For 2024, the top motorcycle helmets include Bell Race Star DLX Flex as the best overall, AGV K6S for budget-conscious buyers, Schuberth C5 as the quietest modular helmet, Shoei Neotec 3 for comfort, and KLIM Krios Pro for adventure-specific needs.
Do Sedici helmets meet DOT approval standards?
Yes, Sedici helmets, such as the Sedici Strada II MIPS, are designed to meet or exceed DOT certification standards. They aim to provide premium quality features at a more affordable, mid-range price.
Is it advisable to keep a Sedici helmet or opt for a different brand?
If safety and quality are your primary concerns and budget is not a limiting factor, you might consider exploring other reputable brands like Arai or Shoei, which are known for their high safety ratings and overall helmet quality. Sedici offers good value for the price but may not match the premium build of some higher-end brands.
